Fair By Design submitted its response to Ofgem's consultation on consumer outcomes as they relate to billing on 19 August 20261. The charity said it is concerned about whether now is the right time for the regulator to remove prescriptive rules, and called for a core set of standards that all energy suppliers must follow1.
Ofgem is moving towards a more outcomes-based approach to regulation, meaning it will be clearer about the outcomes it expects suppliers to achieve while being less prescriptive about how they deliver them1. The consultation is the first step in Ofgem's phased approach to implementing seven consumer outcomes, the first being that "Consumers receive accurate, timely, accessible and understandable energy bills"1.
"We believe a core set of standards that all energy suppliers must follow remains essential for maintaining and building consumer trust."
Fair By Design said minimum standards would also be easier to communicate to consumers and advisers, and would help the Ombudsman judge whether a supplier had done what was expected of it1. It called on Ofgem to work with it and other consumer groups to identify what those minimum standards should be, alongside introducing clear consumer outcomes1.
The response draws on a session with the charity's lived experience panel, whose members described energy bills as opaque and overly complex, contributing to anxiety, disengagement and low levels of trust1. Participants said they often looked only at the amount owed, found the terms debit and credit confusing, and reported difficulty understanding bills, particularly people with dyslexia, autism or lower literacy levels1. Some reported positive experiences of supplier apps1.
On payment methods, Fair By Design said its work on standard credit shows that even when suppliers are incentivised to act in a way that should lead to good consumer outcomes, this does not always happen1. Suppliers are obliged under their licence conditions, and would make money, by encouraging consumers to move off standard credit and onto direct debit, it said1. Ofgem's own research and the charity's own show that less than half of people who pay by standard credit understand that they are paying a premium to do so, and its recent analysis of energy bills found the premium is not always clearly explained, meaning consumers cannot make an informed choice about their payment method1.
Fair By Design also welcomed Ofgem's commitment to be more proactive and to work closely with suppliers, saying the three-year investigation into British Gas forced installation of pre-payment meters "represents the worst of all worlds" because harm was not prevented at an early stage and the process to address it was protracted1.
Why it matters for households
The consultation concerns how energy suppliers' billing practices are regulated, so any change to the rules affects how bills are presented and explained to households across Great Britain1. Fair By Design's central argument is that an outcomes-based approach, on its own, may not deliver clearer bills: it points to standard credit, where a premium applies to paying by bill rather than direct debit, and says fewer than half of those paying it understand they are paying a premium at all1. If minimum standards are not set, the charity argues, consumers and advisers have less certainty about what they can expect from a supplier1.
The billing outcome under consultation covers accuracy, timeliness, accessibility and understandability of bills1. The panel feedback cited by Fair By Design covers comprehension of debit and credit, standing charges, exit fees, credit balances held by suppliers, and how to challenge a bill1. It also covers customer service, the Priority Services Register and switching, including concerns that comparison tools rely on estimates rather than actual consumption1.
What happens next
Ofgem's consultation on consumer outcomes as they relate to billing is described as the first step in a phased approach to implementing seven consumer outcomes1. No date has been reported for the outcome of this consultation or for the introduction of the remaining outcomes. Fair By Design has published its full response and said it is calling on Ofgem to work with it and other consumer groups on identifying minimum standards1.


Financial Ombudsman ServiceFree, independent help when a complaint about a firm is not put right
FSCSProtects your money if a bank, insurer or investment firm fails
FCA Warning ListCheck whether a firm is authorised before you deal with it
MoneyHelperFree, impartial money and pensions guidance, set up by government
Citizens AdviceFree advice on money, consumer and legal problems in England and Wales